On Thu, Feb 21, 2002 at 08:44:18AM -0800, Steve Masover wrote:
> Hi Michael, Tom, et al. --
>
> I'm not sure whether you'll see this as falling within the scope of the
> user@berkeley.edu project you have proposed, but because you are proposing
> that the service be closely integrated with CalNet it occurs to me that a
> similar and very useful functionality might be built into the same
> forwarding server:
>
> Faculty (and other UCB course instructors) have access to student ID
> numbers, but do not as part of the normal business of course registration
> get a list of students' e-mail addresses. What if instructors were able to
> use student IDs as e-mail addresses in order to send course-related
> announcements to enrolled students? I can envision this in a couple of
> different ways. Perhaps the instructors would simply send e-mail to a set
> of student IDs (1234567@berkeley.edu, 2345678@berkeley.edu); or perhaps
> some other application would automatically generate and maintain majordomo
> lists from extant course-enrollment databases (about which I know
> absolutely nothing, so I really have no idea how hard or easy this would
> be) -- so the instructor would mail to something like
> Sociology107_Fall2002@berkeley.edu.
Coincidentally, I was talking with Helen Kelly (Chancellor's Office
Information Systems) yesterday, and she's bringing a proposal to the
EBITF tomorrow for just such a system. I don't know the extent of it
(whether it will support class mailing lists such as the above), but
there is definitely talk about being able to mail to a student ID number
and have it forward to the student. Posession of the student's ID
number is generally considered enough to get around FERPA regulations
(if you have the student ID, you're not a third party, and you can mail
them without bringing up questions of privacy).
I think some people would dislike the idea of being able to mail
everyone in a course using a well-known address, unless it could be
restricted to legitimate users somehow. Spam continues to degrade
our culture of openness.
> I'll take this opportunity to thank you for putting your proposal forward,
> whether my suggestion fits it or not. For years now I've been hearing from
> colleagues and friends at other universities how ridiculous it is that
> UCB's addresses have to be so cumbersome.
And thank you for your comments.
-- Tom Holub (tom_holub@LS.Berkeley.EDU, 510-642-9069) College of Letters & Science 249 Campbell Hall
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Feb 21 2002 - 09:24:09 PST